Tagged: Opinion

Is Advocacy a Cost or an Investment?

October 27, 2026

This is a personal topic for me. Before joining Barfly, I spent 12 years in bar management and operations, on the receiving end of brand advocacy that was sometimes brilliant, sometimes forgettable and occasionally damaging. So, when I see advocacy teams being trimmed across the industry, many of them people I worked with or watched grow from behind the bar into great ambassadors, I have a view.

Cuts were always coming. But I think we are in danger of treating advocacy as a cost to be saved, when it is one of the few things that actually produces long-term profit. The problem is not that it doesn’t work. The problem is that it is hard to prove that it does.

A tough few years, and the cuts to match

Times are hard. People are drinking less; tariffs have hit exports, and the continued focus on health and weight-loss remedies is reducing drinking frequency. Diageo, Moët Hennessy, Brown-Forman and Pernod Ricard have all made cuts to their workforce in the last year by as much as 13%, equating to over 2000 positions. None of this is irrational. The question is which costs go, and how those decisions get made.

Why advocacy is always first in line

When the industry talks about where savings will come from, the language is usually “non-revenue-generating” teams and “non-working” marketing spend. Advocacy sits squarely in that bucket.

You cannot draw a straight line from a masterclass on a Tuesday afternoon to a case sale. An ambassador’s salary and travel are visible on a spreadsheet, but the value they create is spread across hundreds of bars and shows up years later as loyalty that is rarely credited back to them. So advocacy gets labelled a cost centre, not because it doesn’t make money, but because most businesses’ ROI metrics can’t see it.

Advocacy is profit producing, it just pays out slowly

Bartenders are the gatekeepers. They decide what goes on the back bar, what makes the menu, and what gets recommended when a guest says “surprise me”. When people drink less but choose more carefully, that recommendation matters more, not less.

To this day, there are brands I hold dear. The names I give people who ask what to buy will always be the ones I got to taste, learn about and have an incredible time with. I will always love Old Forester bourbon, for example, because I got to share a weekend in Kentucky with a table of incredible bartenders, drink their range, and have the best fried chicken of my life.

Industry commentators have warned that the big groups will feel their advocacy cuts in around three years, as local brands win ground by working the bars when a market leader steps back. We have already seen a regional brewer, by selling only in pubs, turn its home patch into one of the weakest postcodes in the UK for a global brand everyone assumed was untouchable. That is what happens when someone else is in the room and you are not.

We are investing in the wrong bartenders

When budgets shrink, advocacy retreats to the top, to the award-winning bartenders in the most prestigious bars. Their influence does trickle down. But the strongest bonds are formed early. The brand that first takes a young bartender seriously, teaches them something or takes them on their first brand trip wins a loyalty that lasts a career. By the time that bartender is running their own award-winning bar, they will remember who wanted their attention first.

When I became General Manager of my first venue, I knew I wanted Wild Turkey on my back bar. The first time anyone taught me what bourbon actually was, it was the founder himself, with his Brand Ambassador by his side. I kept a signed bottle on my shelf for years.

Some of the people you invest in will leave the industry. But with so many future stars working their way up, the odds are on your side, and it costs far less per head than chasing the same twenty famous names as everyone else.

To be fair, not all advocacy earns its keep

Not every advocacy pound was well spent. Some programmes drifted into travel, parties and freebies with little thought for what they were meant to achieve, and that teaches bartenders a brand only cares when it wants something. So a reset is not necessarily a bad thing. Even now, some of the groups making cuts are still recruiting senior advocacy roles elsewhere in the business. The question is whether the reshaping is driven by evidence or by the easiest line to cut.

The real problem is measurement

If advocacy cannot show its value, it will lose the budget argument every time. Great stories do not survive a cost review run by people who have never worked a bar.

The answer is to track what advocacy actually changes. How bartenders feel about a brand, whether they recommend it and what they say when they do, whether it is on the menu and the back bar, and how that moves over time against the competition. We have been building advocacy tracking and sentiment measures with the trade at Barfly for exactly this reason. Whoever measures it well will still be investing when the market turns.

A saving you can see, against a loss you can’t

It saddens me to see LinkedIn and Instagram posts from people I know were incredible advocates for their brands, ending with “it’s been a great run”. It saddens me more when it feels like the result of intangible outcomes, a lack of data and rash decisions.

Cutting advocacy shows up as a saving on this year’s numbers. The cost comes later, in listings lost, recommendations that go elsewhere, and a generation of bartenders who grew up loyal to someone else. The brands that come out of this downturn strongest will be the ones that kept talking to the people pouring their drinks.

Written by: Ryan Prescott, Strategy Consultant

WE ONLY WORK WITH BRANDS WHO ARE SERIOUS ABOUT SHAPING DRINKS CULTURE

If you’re interested in candid conversations that challenge your brief so you’re creating something culturally significant, we’d love to talk.

SIGN UP TO RECEIVE OUR INSIGHTS

© BARFLY 2024 - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

BARFLY